Monday, December 5, 2011

Wrap-Up

I have to admit I was a bit concerned by picking my favorite publisher as the target of this project.  It might sound silly, but I was a bit worried about finding a nugget of information that would potentially change how I feel about Phaidon.  Happily, I can report, that I found nothing that would change my view of Phaidon.  I think the fact that I would have an emotional reaction at all is probably telling.  I do appreciate the great work that they produce. It's very refreshing today that a larger company takes so much care to produce quality, where so many other companies try to cut as many corners as possible.
Even though it can be said that the scope of my project was limited, I have learned a great deal from it.  To be able to take a just a simple snapshot of merely one aspect of their customer outreach has been phenomenal. Viewing the complexity from a macro-level really made me appreciate the challenge presented to publishers.  To be able to respond to the competition that the Internet presents, leads me to come away with some very salient views; publishers need to wear a lot of hats. 

Creating content for consumers now involves just about every form of media.  I've blogged about many of these elements that need to be created by publishers to meet the expectations of the consuming public.  The print publisher now needs to be videographer to create short snippets supporting their books, or longer full-length productions. Phaidon seems to have leaned towards producing short snippets that end-users can access online via YouTube, or directly from their site.  Regardless of whether or not the publisher is creating video on their own or contracting it out, there must be at the very least a skill set acquired that can evaluate good video from bad.  From a marketing perspective, a bad video snippet can have a very negative effect on the willingness of people to make purchases, but it also damages their perception of the overall quality of your organization. I wonder, if only a decade ago, what the reaction would have been from a publisher if they were told that having to produce and/or evaluate video would become a critical part of their organization.

After dropping off their camera, Phaidon has also had to don their press badge and become news reporter as well.  It's not enough for publishers like Phaidon to just create content.  Phaidon has shown how important and how valuable it is to them to reposition themselves as a hub for a variety of information categories.  News can be a particularly powerful category to gain credibility in.  I think for Phaidon, it only helps to bolster their already sterling amount of authority in their chosen niche. For a consumer, it's helpful to know that you have a credible option for great products, and for news that interests you.  Seeing Phaidon move this way is very encouraging, and it suggests that they have a great grasp on how to compete in the current and future climate online.

Phaidon also is requiring itself to keep it's fingers firmly planted on the pulse of popular culture.  Engaging in social media is a given, and even though I did not track and log its presence in the Twitter-verse and on Facebook, they have very robust social media programs present on both platforms.  However, Phaidon has not stopped at the border of Twitter and Facebook.  They have really branched out into a variety of media channels that many publishers might not even be aware of.  Primarily, and perhaps most strikingly, Phaidon has made indirect connections to the importance and emergence of metadata outside of publishing.  They've accomplished this in a very creative way, by linking artists and music through the service Spotify.  Spotify is much like Pandora, in that they use metadata to suggest music selections based on the music you have previously listened to.

I've danced around this aspect of different hats, but Phaidon has put it's techie hat on as well.  I've blogged about creating interactive websites specifically for books, as was the case for the title "The Silver Spoon."  Though I didn't have an opportunity to cover it, Phaidon has also already created and released a number of apps that can be placed on the iPad and iPhone.  These apps range from city-specific travel apps, to an app that covers 200 years of product design through 1,000 beautiful photographs.

Publishing has never been just about publishing. Since the modern era, there have always been activities beyond acquiring, editing, printing and shipping books.  The information age has not taken away the need for marketing, nor has it stripped publishers of the need to actively promote their titles.  If anything, the Information Age  has added more pressure on a business that is built on the creation of information.  Phaidon has shown that it is rising to the challenge of the Information Age.  By studying just a small aspect of what they do, for a limited time, I've seen first hand how hard publishers have to fight, and how far they have to stretch themselves.  This might be viewed by some as a reason to jump-ship, and leave the industry.  However, I don't share that viewpoint.  When I look at the way Phaidon has conducted themselves, I see hope instead.  A publisher can rise to the challenge, and a publisher can reposition itself in a way that will allow for success in the future, and I believe that the future will continue to be bright for Phaidon.

Good Night and Good Luck, Phaidon as News Agent

We've talked extensively in class about how the necessity on the part of publishers to respond to the digital age. Content is being consumed at rates unseen before in the history of humanity, and the challenge and reward to publishers is to find a way to put themselves at the center of conversations.  Publishers like Phaidon do this initially by creating great content, and in the past, that was enough. However, in the future and to a certain extent now, pushing out great content is not enough and you have to reinvent yourself.  Phaidon has accomplished this, and would seem to be ahead of the curve, by partially remaking itself as a news agent in the spheres they publish in.

You can see this clearly by visiting their Homepage. It could be just a coincidence, and it could be merely a design choice that is being misinterpreted by me, but Phaidon's current website design is eerily similar to that of an online newspaper. Perhaps that design was selected because it is very clean and very simple.  Because of this design's simplicity, it definitely generates a large "pop" for the wonderful photography that's a mainstay in Phaidon's work.  Regardless, I think the coincidences end when you realize that the homepage is also called "Agenda".  If this is all a coincidence, then it can't be argued that they have clearly moved away from the color design- heavy page that they used to operate in 2005 (see image on right).

One of the aspects I really enjoy about Phaidon is that they are an advocate for the arts. Yes, they are in the business of selling books about art, but they also clearly care a great deal about the topic they cover.  They spend a good amount of energy it would seem, in covering topics that have very little to do with the books they sell, and are genuinely interested in giving insight to their readership.  Case in point, one of my newly discovered favorite features Phaidon produces is the "Muse Music" feature.  I discovered this through an email that was sent, and the feature interviews an artist, and asks them to divulge what music they're listening to when they work and why.  In the most current edition, Muse Music features artist Martin Boyce, and actually links to some of his favorite tracks on the music service Spotify.

In the tracking project, news stories were the most heavily reported topic.  There were 36 news stories in total, and many of them chronicled the works and exhibitions that were currently under way for many artists that appear in Phaidon's books.  However, this is not to suggest that the news stories were simply fluff for selling books, by visiting their site you can see Phaidon takes great care in covering entire art festivals like this news event at the V&A in London.

Phaidon is clearly trying to establish themselves as a premiere place on the web to receive news that matters in the art world.  It actually makes a great deal of sense, as Phaidon already produces some of the best printed content, and they have already garnered authority in the field.  This expansion into reporting news is a natural extension, and a very wise one.

Bias Alert! Bias Alert!

So this post was always destined to be my favorite. I mentioned earlier why I selected Phaidon, and it was because I found them by looking for the work of Steve McCurry. For those of you who don't know Steve by name, you're more than likely familiar with his work...as he probably captured one of the most recognizable photos of the last 40 Years. As a fan of photography my entire life, Phaidon became the first publisher that I recognized as a brand in and of themselves.  Since finding Phaidon I also located a number of other wonderful publishers such as Magnum, but Phaidon was the first, so they'll always have a special place in my heart.

One of the aspects I truly appreciate about Phaidon is that they're not just about selling books, they really are an advocate of sharing art, and giving their readership insight and access into the artists themselves.  For me in particular, it was especially exciting to come across a video series they had developed with Steve McCurry called Steve McCurry's One-Minute Masterclass, which is exactly what it sounds like. For free, the visitor to the site gets to take in a number of one-minute video's that were produced by Phaidon interviewing Steve on a number of topics geared toward helping the budding photographer to become better at his or her craft.  For me, it was a real opportunity to completely nerd-out, and it's always special to be able to hear from professionals that you respect share their hard-earned knowledge.

The category of film and photography was well represented in the tracking project.  There were no newly released titles in photography, but as one would expect from Phaidon, they have a tremendous backlist that they were promoting.  There were 12 seperate topics that were marketed via email, spanning a signed copy of Steve McCurry's book (if anyone needs any last-minute Christmas gift ideas), to books about Tim Burton and Clint Eastwood.  Also, there were 6 separate news stories that included works being exhibited or created  by Phaidon covered artists.

Of Course the Book Weighs 19 Pounds...

Along with starting to track Phaidon at the time of a newly released cookbook, I was really treated to catch the publisher as they were releasing out into the wild and absolute monster of a book from the Exhibition Art category.  What especially exciting about this particular book is that it represents exactly what Phaidon was created for; making high-quality books cover art.  To say that The Art Museum, covers art is perhaps one of the largest understatements in the history of publishing.  Just to give you some sort of idea about this size of this book, yes it does weigh-in at 19 coffee-table-punishing pounds, but the weight is only one factor.  The book features about 1,000 over-sized pages of over 2,500 works of art.  And as you'd come to expect from Phaidon, the photography reproduction looks absolutely amazing.  This book is huge in another way than just size; it's perhaps the largest and most comprehensive collection of art from around the world in one volume.  It's really a stunning achievement that you don't have to be an art afficionado to appreciate.

Phaidon marketed this book effectively via email. Again, as this was a new release, I received an email that was completely and solely devoted to this single title.  Interestingly enough, the book is currently discounted when you visit it's landing page on Phaidon's home site, but the email doesn't mention anything about price or discounting.  What the email does offer is a look into the sheer size of the material covered.  It also links to an interview given by the author to NPR, which was very interesting to listen to.  I'd seriously encourage anyone reading who is interested in art to take a peek at the home page.  Phaidon has created a brief video on YouTube embedded on the site that describes the book, an gives you additional information.

This book is seriously the embodiment of why I love Phaidon so much, they really are a tremendous publisher.

As it pertains to this tracking project, most of the emailing efforts were directed at The Art Musuem, however, there were other titles promoted.  There were 16 total topics discussed in various emails over the course of the tracking project.  Also, there were 19 news stories related directly to exhibitions, or work currently being developed by artists covered by books published by Phaidon.

"Yes, I'll Have the Hardcover, With A Heaping Helping of Awesome, Thanks"

One of the categories of books that I had no idea Phaidon published dealt with cooking and initially that was surprising to me.  However, it makes sense that Phaidon would publish cooking titles because when done right, food can truly be art (often around me it's very temporary art).  Someone once said that you eat with your eyes, and while my stomach has never been filled by staring at a plate of perfectly cooked Italian food, I can see their point.  Even more surprisingly, the cooking category of topics were well represented, and was actually the first email that I had received from Phaidon after joining their email list.

I was fortunate enough to start tracking Phaidon right as they released the first edition of The Family Meal: Home Cooking with Ferran Adria. It was exciting to begin with a new release to see how the publisher would deal with it from a marketing perspective.  I think one of the most prominent aspects of the marketing campaign was that via email, "The Family Meal" was marketed by itself.  Phaidon ensured that this particular book was going to be the sole focus of that particular email. The email was, of course, designed in the same style as Phaidons' website, very clean and effective.  They included some visuals directly from the book, and each would link back to the landing page for the book on the home website.  The visuals themselves looked stunning, even only as small images embedded in the email.

In terms of sales, this was one of the rarer occurrences where Phaidon offered a discount.  This is not to suggest that Phaidon is in any way a stingy publisher. Every book that I have purchased from Phaidon has been of the highest quality.  The photography is expertly produced, the paper is always high quality, and the books are just constructed to last, and this title seems no different.  As a consumer you expect to pay more for that quality, so it was nice to see Phaidon offer a discount of 30% off the list price.  Upon last checking the home page for this work, it seems like the marketing efforts were effective, as the book is currently out of stock (a nice problem to have).

In all Phaidon did a great job of promoting this entire category, and not just because they had a new release.  Throughout the project, they would intermingle in cooking backlist titles. In one particular email, there were a number of recipes from the title The Silver Spoon, which linked directly from the email to a landing page that gives away free content from the book. In fact, there's a whole website devoted to this particularly popular and long running title.  Within that website consumers can read a lot of content for free, including information on the different cooking regions of Italy.

For Phaidon, the cooking category is one that they clearly believe in and support.  Within the total number of topics logged, there were twenty topics devoted to the cooking books.  Also there were five news stories directly related to food, or to authors of Phaidon books on cooking.  Bon appetit!

Uh-oh...Here Comes the Numbers.

I'll be honest when not at work in my cube, I'm not a huge fan of dealing with numbers.  My Grandfather was a chemical engineer, and my Father was a systems analyst for the Navy...I can barely add.  The prospect of dealing with a volume of numbers is daunting, but I think it's necessary to start the analysis of Phaidon's direct marketing efforts via email with a look at the sheer numbers.

I started receiving emails from Phaidon shortly after setting up this blog and joining their emailing list in mid-September. I kept collecting data from that point until the end of November to give myself a few days to distill down the data.

From September 19th, which was the first email occurrence, until the last email from November 30th, here are the raw numbers:

Total number of emails:  23

Total number of topic subjects:  11

Total number of themed emails: 6

Total number of topics: 124

A quick word about "topics" and "topic subjects" and how these are defined.  I'm defining topics as individual stories, offers, profiles, etc., that were included in the emails I received.  A topic could range from a news story about an artist exhibition, to an advertisement for a new book, to an announcement of a offers for sales of signed copies.

Topic subjects refers to the containers I have created that the topics fall into.  In keeping with the example above, a topic about an artist exhibition would fall in the "news" topic subject, while an offer for a photography book would fall into the "book: photography/film" topic subject, and an offer for a signed copy of a new design book would fall into the "book: design" topic subject.

Finally, below is what my color-coded Excel spreadsheet ended up looking like:

















Where'yah Been?

If Phaidon were a woman I was dating, she would have left long, long ago.  You see, I've been avoiding Phaidon on purpose, but not because I'm following "dude code" or something akin to the high school rules of dating.  Though it wasn't my intention, it turned out that I felt Phaidon and I needed some time apart.  I had an idea, I wanted to see how a publisher reached out to me when I wasn't reaching out to the publisher...selfish I know. I'll share below my methodology and what kind of data I was tracking. 

In the beginning I wanted to stay strictly with social media, then I had to make some decisions on what I would log and track: 

I decided to not track Facebook and Twitter. 

Yeah...I know...I just said I wanted to track social media and then I immediately negate the two largest social media sites.  The problem I found with Twitter and Facebook was that they were not directed at me necessarily.  Yes, Phaidon takes great pains to have a very robust Twitter Channel and in fact they have multiple accounts that I do follow.  The problem with this approach would have been logging literally hundreds of Tweets (secretly, and most importantly, Phaidon didn't follow me on Twitter and I felt scorned, yes, that's a joke).  But, aside from the volume, I didn't feel that it was something that was directed at me individually.  Yes, social media is not passive, and a Tweet from Phaidon would be much like a ringing phone and a ringing phone must be answered.  However, I thought that for this project a complete social media study would simply not be very interesting.  I would have been dealing in numbers and I think that's missing the point.

Tracking Facebook was an aspect of the project I was on the fence about. I'll be honest, I absolutely LOVE their Facebook page.  Phaidon offers something interesting almost every day.  Most of the time they provide links back to their site for video and news (a topic I will cover later), and I've found most of the content engaging.  However, I opted not to track Facebook either.  The reasons were much the same as not tracking Twitter, while not as voluminous, I found that it wasn't as personalized an experience as I would have liked. If I wasn't on Facebook, I found myself not thinking much about Phaidon's presence there. Even when I was on Facebook, often I'd forget to check their page because a picture of an "LOL Cat" is something so rare that it can't be missed right? Did I mention I have the attention span of a gnat some times?

Instead, I opted for direct marketing.  It's very tough to beat waking up in the morning and finding a little gem in your email inbox from Phaidon.  This is the experience that for me personally is more effective.  When I received emails from Phaidon, I paid more attention to them.  Even though direct email does share some of the same attributes of Twitter in that it's active rather than passive, the flow of emails was much more measured and less in-your-face.  

After joining Phaidon's mailing list with my school account, I promptly began to receive emails and then I was pressed to think about: Now what?  It became very clear after the first two emails that I needed to create some sort of tracking mechanism that would allow me to look at the volume of data in a way that made sense.  Phaidon knows what they're doing in how they communicate, so it became up to me to figure it out.  After spending some time on their website and getting a grip on all the categories of publishing they play in, it became very obvious to me that the main field of data to parse out would be category.  
So, I created and Excel spreadsheet that would contain the following categories:
News;
Books in Art Exhibition
Books in Design
Books in Film/ Photography
Books in Food/cooking
Children's books
Apps
Special Features

I also began to log whether or not there were special offers or price breaks on their books.

So that is essentially the sum total my methodology.  I'll start to fill in an discuss the data in subsequent posts.  Thanks for staying awake long enough to get to the bottom of this post!





How I Stopped Worrying and Learned to Love Android...or at least enjoy it.

So before I get into the rest of the publisher tracking, I thought that sharing my experience with the Nook Color now would be appropriate, because...well, I'm thinking about it!

Just for the sake of disclosure, I do own a Nook product.  This summer, before beginning the semester, I talked myself into purchasing the NOOK Simple Touch and really enjoyed it.  However, in the back of my mind, there was always a bit of a bug to see how much I would enjoy a color media tablet.  After all, e-Ink is great, it's easy on the eyes and it's just like picking up a printed book, but let's face it, you can't play Angry Birds on it, and surfing the web is not the best experience.  Also, while not directly owning and iPad, I have been fortunate enough to sit with one extensively.  I found the iPad to be incredibly enjoyable, easy to use, responsive and it just delivered content effortlessly.  I was hoping to have the same experience with the NOOK Color.

For the most part, I have to say that the experience with NOOK was great.  Much like the Simple Touch, the NOOK Color was lightweight, seemed like a good build and the felt great in my hand. The smaller size of the device made it very easy to handle, and the device just worked well in terms of fitting into how I would like to use it.  I could very easily lay down on the couch with it, recline, and sit at the table with the NOOK just as easily as I could the iPad.  In fact, after sitting with it for lengthy periods of time, the NOOK seemed a bit lighter than the iPad.

In terms of the experience as a media tablet, I was pleasantly surprised here too.  Though there was detectable lag often in moving from web page to page, the NOOK handled all media well.  Is it as responsive as the iPad, no.  But that doesn't mean it was a bad experience, and for half the price of an iPad, I'd seriously consider purchasing it as an alternative.

Thinking about the reading experience with the NOOK and how I would write about was difficult.  I should make it very clear that I enjoyed it, but I found out something very important about myself:  when given technology and access to the web, I suddenly have the attention span of gnat. I have to admit that I found my finger, as I was reading, begin to wander down ever closer to the well designed home button shaped like an "N".   The little "N" that would take me away from the book I was reading and off to check some of my favorite online magazines, my favorite teams sites, and newspapers.  Granted, the content that I was reading wasn't the most interesting, but I still found myself wanting to make use of the NOOK primarily as a media tablet and less as an eReader.

Ultimately, would I purchase the NOOK Color? Possibly. Being and iPhone owner however, I'm most likely going to purchase an iPad when I move into the media tablet market. That doesn't mean I felt the NOOK Color was a bad product, far from it, the problems I was experiencing had more to do with my toddler-like attention span than any faulty programming or product build issues on the part of NOOK.  But I did figure out something very important, if I'm going to have an eReader, I'd much prefer owning one that is dedicated to eReading...then maybe I'll have to pick up a media tablet as a toy down the road.